My experience at NewYork-Presbyterian was challenging in ways I did not anticipate. I came into this role confident, motivated, and excited to contribute. Unfortunately, over time, the environment within my team began to negatively affect my confidence and overall experience at work.
What stands out most to me is that I did not like who I was becoming while working on this team. I found myself second-guessing my abilities, feeling constantly on edge, and losing some of the confidence I had when I first joined the organization. I came in confident and, in many ways, left feeling defeated.
A significant part of the difficulty was the management style within the team. There were instances where members of management provided conflicting information or different directions, creating unnecessary confusion around expectations. At times, employees could follow the direction they were given only to later receive different guidance.
There was also a lack of consistency regarding job responsibilities. Employees could be hired for a particular role or set of responsibilities and later find that their duties had been significantly changed or shifted based on management decisions. Changes in business needs are understandable, but substantial changes to an employee’s role should involve transparent communication and discussion rather than leaving the employee feeling as though the position they accepted is no longer the position they are performing.
Communication was another concern. There were occasions when members of the team were spoken to in a manner that I felt was rude, dismissive, or unnecessarily disrespectful. Constructive feedback is part of any workplace, but how that feedback is delivered matters. Employees should be able to ask questions, make mistakes, and receive guidance without feeling belittled or uncomfortable.
Another significant concern was professional growth and internal mobility. My experience left me with the impression that employees could face resistance when attempting to pursue opportunities on other teams within the organization. It was particularly discouraging to feel that team members could be treated poorly within their current environment while simultaneously feeling restricted from pursuing opportunities elsewhere within NYP.
An organization as large as NYP has tremendous opportunities for employees to develop their careers. Managers should encourage strong employees to grow, even when that growth means moving to another department. Retaining talent within the organization should be more important than retaining an individual on one particular team.
Perhaps the most concerning issue was the level of fear surrounding honest feedback. In my experience, some employees did not feel comfortable answering employee surveys honestly because they feared their responses could somehow be identified or result in retaliation. When employees feel safer providing a favorable response than an honest one, leadership may receive an inaccurate picture of the team’s culture and the underlying problems remain unchanged.
This creates a cycle where employees are unhappy but afraid to speak openly, survey results do not necessarily reflect what employees are actually experiencing, and meaningful change does not occur. Employees need a genuinely safe and confidential way to provide feedback and confidence that raising concerns will not negatively affect them.
There were certainly opportunities to learn and grow, and I gained valuable experience during my time at NYP. However, employees perform at their best when expectations are consistent and they feel respected, supported, and trusted by leadership.
I am leaving with valuable professional lessons, but also with a much clearer understanding of the type of work environment and leadership I need in order to do my best work. I hope greater attention is given to management communication, consistency, role expectations, employee treatment, internal career mobility, and psychological safety.
I came into NYP confident in my abilities. I never expected to leave feeling defeated.