Senior Property Manager - Operations Lead (Residential, AppFolio)
Justin Udy & Team is seeking a Property Management Operations Manager to operate and scale our residential rental portfolio from 50 units growing to 100+. This is a client-facing, operations-driven role designed for a proven property management professional who thrives in a fast-paced environment and takes true ownership of systems, service, and results.
The ideal candidate has a strong track record of success in property management, demonstrates exceptional organization, and exercises sound business judgment in daily decision-making. This role requires a high level of professionalism, integrity, and fairness, along with an acute focus on tenant experience, owner communication, and long-term asset performance.
You’ll be responsible for overseeing day-to-day operations, including tenant relations, maintenance coordination, vendor management, and accurate financial reporting, while helping implement and refine systems that support growth and scalability. We’re looking for a leader who values service, structure, and accountability, and who takes pride in managing and enhancing significant real estate assets. This role reports directly to Justin Udy.
This is a career PM role, plus an outside-sales policy. This is a full-time, primarily in-office position based in Sandy / Cottonwood Heights area, with local property visits needed. If you enjoy ownership, systems, and service — and want to help scale something meaningful — we’d love to hear from you. Apply today.
Tenant & Owner Relations
- Serve as the primary point of contact for tenants and property owners
- Resolve tenant concerns professionally, calmly, and in alignment with company standards
- Maintain clear, accurate documentation of all communication within AppFolio
- Ensure tenants feel heard, owners feel informed, and expectations are consistently managed
- Answer inbound phone calls and inquiries related to property management and rentals
Property Management Operations (50–100+ Units)
- Oversee rent collection, delinquencies, notices, and lease enforcement
- Manage move-ins, move-outs, renewals, inspections, and security deposit accounting
- Prepare and review monthly owner statements through AppFolio
- Ensure all financial data is entered accurately to support automated reporting
- Maintain compliance with Fair Housing laws and Utah property management regulations
- Monitor expenses, vacancy, collections, maintenance costs, and management revenue against approved owner and company targets.
Leasing, Pricing & Portfolio Growth
- Advertise available units and leverage referrals to attract qualified tenants
- Establish and recommend competitive rental pricing by analyzing market data, expenses, and asset goals
- Monitor prospects, leasing activity, and vacancy trends to support portfolio growth
- Show rental units as needed, execute leases and addenda (license required)
- Support onboarding of new properties and management clients as the portfolio scales
Maintenance & Vendor Management
- Triage maintenance requests and determine urgency and scope
- Obtain, review, and evaluate repair bids based on cost, necessity, and long-term value
- Coordinate vendors, approve work within guidelines, and follow through to completion
- Track preventative maintenance schedules and recurring service needs
- Communicate repair recommendations and outcomes clearly with property owners
What Success Looks Like
- Phones answered consistently and professionally
- Owner statements delivered cleanly and on time every month
- Maintenance issues handled quickly with sound judgment
- Portfolio stabilized and prepared to scale toward 100+ units
- Owners feel confident, tenants feel supported, and systems run smoothly
A valid Real Estate License (Required) 2+ years in property management or real estate operations Comfortable on the phone with tenants, owners, and vendors Possess the ability to connect with a variety of personalities on the phone and in person Strong understanding of residential maintenance and repairs Excellent computer skills, including Microsoft Office Experience with property management software (AppFolio and/or TenantCloud a plus) Organized, calm under pressure, and process-oriented Reliable transportation for property visits and showings Monitoring weekend and evening hour emergency is required